Skip to main content

Table 1 The fermentation characteristics of alfalfa silage

From: Effect of soil contamination and additives on fermentative profile, microbial community and iron bioaccessibility of alfalfa silage

Item

Soil level (%)

Additives

SEM

Significance

Con

LP

MLP

S

A

S × A

pH values

0

5.93a ± 0.05

4.95bB ± 0.04

4.71bB ± 0.19

0.018

 < 0.001

 < 0.001

0.071

1.5

5.91a ± 0.08

4.94bB ± 0.01

4.82cAB ± 0.02

    

7.5

5.95a ± 0.01

5.18bA ± 0.04

5.06bA ± 0.07

    

LA

(g kg−1 DM)

0

17.3bAB ± 1.47

39.4abA ± 1.29

46.8a ± 9.75

1.641

0.548

 < 0.001

0.952

1.5

20.1bA ± 0.60

37.3aAB ± 0.16

41.8a ± 5.95

    

7.5

14.2bB ± 0.25

35.6aB ± 0.63

40.6a ± 3.18

    

AA

(g kg−1 DM)

0

14.1a ± 0.58

10.4bA ± 0.08

12.9a ± 0.24

0.433

0.094

 < 0.001

0.485

1.5

14.6a ± 1.18

7.2bB ± 0.80

14.2ab ± 2.52

    

7.5

12.2a ± 0.93

6.5bB ± 0.42

11.7a ± 0.58

    

PA

(g kg−1 DM)

0

8.3bA ± 0.41

8.6bA ± 0.15

16.4aA ± 0.46

0.183

 < 0.001

 < 0.001

0.045

1.5

5.7cB ± 0.13

6.7bB ± 0.27

15.8aA ± 0.01

    

7.5

4.6bB ± 0.30

4.5bC ± 0.58

11.0aB ± 0.94

    

BA

(g kg−1 DM)

0

1.0aB ± 0.07

0.3bC ± 0.05

NDc ± 0.01

0.057

 < 0.001

 < 0.001

0.004

1.5

0.6aB ± 0.01

0.4bB ± 0.07

NDc ± 0.01

    

7.5

2.2aA ± 0.39

0.9bA ± 0.03

0.1b ± 0.08

    

AN

(g kg−1 TN)

0

111.3aB ± 2.35

51.4cC ± 0.40

59.4bB ± 0.19

0.724

 < 0.001

 < 0.001

 < 0.001

1.5

118.0aB ± 3.64

50.0bB ± 1.67

55.6bC ± 0.23

    

7.5

156.4aA ± 1.05

65.6cA ± 1.83

74.9bA ± 1.45

    
  1. DM, dry matter; TN, total nitrogen
  2. LA, lactic acid; AA, acetic acid; PA, propionic acid, BA, butyric acid; AN, ammonia nitrogen
  3. Con, control; LP, Lactobacillus plantarum inoculant alone; MLP, combination addition of molasses and Lactobacillus plantarum inoculant
  4. SEM, error of the means; S, soil contamination levels; A, additives; S × A, interaction between soil contamination levels and additives. Means within the same row (a, b) or within the same column (A, B) with different superscript differ significantly from each other (P < 0.05)